What should you ask before you sign a contract?
Ask each company to confirm five things in writing: their state license and insurance, the installers' certifications, the target R-value the job will reach, whether air-sealing is included, and the total price and scope.
- License and insuranceConfirm both are current and cover work in your state.
- Target R-value in writingThe one number every bid should be held to equally.
- Is air sealing included?If a contractor won't air-seal first, ENERGY STAR says call someone else.

A company that treats the R-value as a vague "we'll fill it up" is one you cannot hold to a standard - and the R-value is the one number the FTC's rule exists to protect. Ask for documentation at the end of the job showing the R-value actually achieved.
What are the red flags?
The FTC lists demands for an on-the-spot decision, and requests to pay the whole job up front or in cash, as classic home-improvement scam signs. Other warning signs: no verifiable state license or proof of insurance, no written scope, and no documentation promised at the end of the job.
Sources
2 cited- What to verify before signing, and R-Value Rule disclosure: ENERGY STAR, How to Hire an Attic Insulation Contractor, 2024; Federal Trade Commission, Final Amendments to the R-Value Rule for Home Insulation, 2018 (checked 2026-08-19).
- Home-improvement fraud red flags: Federal Trade Commission, Spot and Avoid Home-Related Fraud, 2022 (checked 2026-08-19).
